The Associate Dean for Scientific Affairs (Prof. Dr. Hossam Abd Ali Muhammad) from the College of Education for Pure Sciences/University of Karbala participated in the discussion committee for a PhD thesis in the Department of Mathematics at the College of Education for Pure Sciences/University of Babylon, tagged Solving semidefinite Programming of NP-hardness Problems Solving quasi-definite programming for NP-hardness problems), for PhD student (Ahmed Hassan Hamid Mahmoud), and the student got the grade of excellence.